ACM Global Technology Policy Council Releases Joint Statement on Principles for Responsible Algorithmic Systems by US and Europe Policy Committees
New York, NY, October 26, 2022 – The Association for Computing Machinery’s global Technology Policy Council (TPC) has released a new Statement on Principles for Responsible Algorithmic Systems authored jointly by its US (USTPC) and Europe Technology Policy Committees (Europe TPC). Recognizing that algorithmic systems are increasingly used by governments and companies to make or recommend decisions that have far-reaching effects on individuals, organizations, and society, the ACM Statement lays out nine instrumental principles intended to foster fair, accurate, and beneficial algorithmic decision-making.
The statement includes a definition for each principle as well as a brief explanation of how the principle contributes to the larger goal of building responsible algorithmic systems. The nine instrumental principles include: Legitimacy and Competency; Minimizing Harm; Security and Privacy; Transparency; Interpretability and Explainability; Maintainability; Contestability and Auditability; Accountability and Responsibility; and Limiting Environmental Impacts. The new statement complements the ACM Code of Ethics and is intended as a guide for algorithm developers and designers to remain vigilant concerning the potential for bias and unfairness at each stage of the software development process.
“We are building on our 2017 Statement on Algorithmic Transparency and Accountability with principles that urge designers and developers to produce sufficient evidence of the legitimacy and reliability of automated systems, so that users do not need to place blind trust in them,” explained Jeanna Matthews, a Professor at Clarkson University and Co-Lead author of the new Statement. “Processes to collect and share this critical information transparently throughout a system’s lifecycle is key to responsible deployment of algorithmic systems in collaboration with all the stakeholders impacted by a system.”
“This statement improves upon the first one in several aspects,” added Ricardo Baeza-Yates, Professor, Universitat Pompeu Fabra, and Co-Lead author of the new Statement. “We include two new key instrumental principles: legitimacy and competence. These define the validity of an algorithmic system as well as sustainability that worries about our future on Earth. We also discuss governance aspects, including how to put these principles into practice by giving a number of examples of trade-offs to consider.”
In addition to the nine instrumental principles, the ACM Technology Policy Council recognizes that, despite putting in place a framework to discourage bias in algorithms, several factors could produce unfair systems. For these reasons, the Statement on Principles for Responsible Algorithmic Systems includes four recommendations which take into account the way data is processed and how a system is deployed.
- System builders and operators should adhere to the same standards in selecting inputs or architecting systems to which humans are held when making equivalent decisions
- AI system developers should undertake extensive impact assessments prior to the deployment of AI systems
- Policy makers should mandate that audit trails be used to achieve higher standards of accuracy, transparency, and fairness
- Operators of AI systems should be held responsible for their decisions regardless of whether algorithmic tools are used
Members of the ACM Technology Policy Council also recognize that a “one size fits all” approach to achieving responsible algorithmic systems would be ineffective and that context plays an important role in each developer’s decisions. ACM TPC members hope that the Statement on Principles for Responsible Algorithmic Systems will prompt discussions among all stakeholders, initiate more research, and help leaders develop governance methods to bring benefits to a wide range of users while promoting the reliability, safety, and responsibility of algorithmic systems.
About the ACM US Technology Policy Committee
ACM’s US Technology Policy Committee (USTPC) serves as the focal point for ACM's interaction with all branches of the US government, the computing community, and the public on policy matters related to information technology. The Committee regularly educates and informs Congress, the Administration, and the courts about significant developments in the computing field and how those developments affect public policy in the United States.
About ACM Europe TPC
The ACM Europe Technology Policy Committee (ACM Europe TPC) promotes dialogue and the exchange of ideas on technology and computing policy issues with the European Commission and other governmental bodies in Europe, and the informatics and computing communities. The Europe TPC engages promotes sound public policy and public understanding of a broad range of issues at the intersection of technology and policy. Its policy statements reflect the expertise of ACM Europe Council professional members from the public and private sectors experienced in informatics, computer science, and other computing-related subjects.
ACM, the Association for Computing Machinery, is the world's largest educational and scientific computing society, uniting educators, researchers, and professionals to inspire dialogue, share resources, and address the field's challenges. ACM strengthens the computing profession's collective voice through strong leadership, promotion of the highest standards, and recognition of technical excellence. ACM supports the professional growth of its members by providing opportunities for life-long learning, career development, and professional networking.